Not long ago, a former employee lingering at the chef’s table asked Lauren Hirschberg whether he ever looks around Turtle and the Wolf, the Montclair restaurant he has run for 11 years, and thinks, hell yeah.
No, he told her. Never.
Then he took it back. “Every now and then I’ll kind of just sit back by the coffee station and just see, you know, servers coming and going and plates going out and people just kind of buzzing and raising their glasses and having a good time,” Hirschberg told Farnoosh Torabi and Mike Schreiber on The Montclair Pod. “And I’m kind of like, man, this is pretty dope. I created this. We pulled this off.”
The tables still fill. But a rent increase of close to 25%, rising food costs and a state liquor license system that shuts out owners like him have Hirschberg wondering whether he would open a restaurant in New Jersey at all if he started over.
How Turtle and the Wolf Helped Build Upper Montclair’s Restaurant Scene
Hirschberg grew up riding his bike to Carvel and eating his first sushi at Daikichi. He spent more than a decade at Tom Colicchio’s Craft, eventually running culinary operations for the group. When he came home in 2015, Uptown looked nothing like it does now.
“I don’t want to use dramatic words, but it was kind of bleak,” he said.
What convinced him was a dinner at CulinAriane, Ariane Duarte’s restaurant on Walnut Street. Six friends crowded around a table next to the stove for the tasting menu. The bill came to about $150 a head, before a single drink, at a place booked months in advance.
“I was like, whoa, there’s a whole market here of people who want to spend money on good food,” Hirschberg said.
The last push came from Manhattan. His bosses there shot down his plan to renovate the aging restaurant he ran. The next day, his childhood friend and business partner Matt Trevenen texted him about an empty storefront on Valley Road. Turtle and the Wolf opened there in fall 2015.
The town showed up. His fifth-grade gym teacher left a postcard remembering him diving around the soccer field as a goalie.
The block has filled in since, with Minoru in the old Daikichi space, Clementina across the street and Dan and Day’s nearby. Mike argues that, pound for pound, Upper Montclair may now have the best food per square foot in the state, and that Turtle and the Wolf started it.
Eleven years of full books, though, have not added up to a safety net.
Rising Rent and the Cost of Running a Restaurant in New Jersey
The squeeze starts in the kitchen. Hirschberg estimates that his cost of goods, what he pays for ingredients and supplies, has risen 35% to 40% over the past decade. Raising prices is the obvious fix, and the one he resists. He wants Turtle and the Wolf to stay the place where people stop in off the train for a quick steak frites at the counter.
“If it starts to become too expensive and people feel like it’s too precious, I think you lose what the heart of that restaurant is,” he said.
Then came the lease. After the first five years, Hirschberg negotiated a pause on rent increases. At the next renewal, the landlord brought the rent up to where it would have been without the pause, close to 25% in one jump, with annual increases of 3% to 5% after that.
“I said to the landlord, I was like, you know you’re basically just assigning us a slow death,” Hirschberg said. “And he was like, well, this is what I have to do. The rent is what the rent is.”
Those couple thousand dollars a month used to be his profit. Now he pays himself a set salary, and little else reaches the bottom line.
“If I do want to consider making more money because I have a teenage daughter now and I have to start thinking about tuition payments and stuff like that, that means that there’s an employee that maybe I can’t have at my restaurant because I need to take their salary to live my life,” he said. “And that’s the last thing that I ever want to do.”
He added lunch service, which helps only slightly. Dinner reservations are already maxed out, so the one lever left to pull belongs to Trenton.
Why a New Jersey Liquor License Is Still Out of Reach
What Hirschberg can’t buy is a liquor license. Drinks carry some of the biggest markups on a restaurant check, and as a BYOB, Turtle and the Wolf earns nothing on them. As the Pod has reported, New Jersey caps full liquor licenses at one for every 3,000 residents. That leaves Montclair with about 13 for roughly 300 restaurants, and they have sold here for more than $1 million.
“It makes them into million-dollar commodities that are privately owned,” Hirschberg said. “And unless you’re a chain, really, or you have really deep pockets, you kind of are priced out of playing that game.”
The workarounds don’t solve much. One lets a restaurant partner with a single New Jersey winery and sell its bottles, acting as a showroom for a small cut of each sale. “It is a workaround,” Hirschberg said. “But I don’t really think it’s that financially beneficial, nor do I think it elevates the experience with interesting offerings.”
The rules don’t apply evenly, either. A few hundred feet away, DeNovo serves beer, wine and cocktails because it sits on NJ Transit property, which falls outside the cap.
Small restaurants have tried to change that. A few years ago, chefs including Ehren Ryan of Common Lot in Millburn and the team at Heirloom Kitchen in Old Bridge pushed for a cheaper license allowing beer and wine with table service only. It never passed. Ryan closed Common Lot in May 2025 and told The Digest the failed reform was “a big factor.”
The 2024 overhaul let towns reclaim so-called pocket licenses, ones that owners hold without using, and lets some move to neighboring towns. Hirschberg says they tend to land with developers who already have the money to use them.
Trenton says it wants to help — and the governor is not a stranger to the dining room. Asked whether Gov. Mikie Sherrill, who represented the district in Congress before becoming governor, has ever eaten at Turtle and the Wolf, Hirschberg said yes. Sherrill dined there, he recalled, around the time she won her seat in Congress. On Nov. 10, as governor, she signed Executive Order No. 28, branded New Jersey Means Business, which directs state agencies to make New Jersey friendlier to employers. Farnoosh doubts faster permits will reach a place like Turtle and the Wolf. Its problem, she said, is unit economics, the math of what each dish costs to make versus what it brings in: rent goes up, and the only way to cover it is to charge more for the same plate.
Would He Open a Restaurant in New Jersey Again?
For Hirschberg, the stakes reach past his own paycheck. A higher check average, the typical bill per table, would mean bigger tips, better benefits and higher wages for his staff. He calls it a rising tide that lifts all boats.
“I have servers who are like, this is what I want to do as my job. This is what I enjoy as a career,” he said. “And it just really sucks that, for a restaurant that they really enjoy, they’re really proud of, they love being at, and a group of people that they really consider to be friends and family at this point, that for them to really make more money, they would have to leave and go work in a restaurant that does have a liquor license.”
He has reasons to stay. He still plays hockey with guys he played with in high school, and he points out the Montclair High amphitheater to his kids as the place he hung out at lunch. But he talks to friends running restaurants in other states.
“It’s night and day of what we have to deal with,” he said. “Maybe if I were to do it over again I would consider things differently, and it might not be that Lauren Hirschberg is a Jersey guy anymore.”
What frustrates him most is how close New Jersey already is. Chefs like him trained in New York’s best kitchens, then crossed the river for a yard and a garage. Farmland stretches west. Philadelphia sits at the other end of the Turnpike. What the state keeps getting instead, he said, is another sports bar off another highway.
“We have such talent, arm’s length away, but we could have the greatest restaurant culture of any state if we wanted to,” he said.
Until the law changes, the surest way to keep Turtle and the Wolf on Valley Road is the simplest: book a table, bring a bottle and try the lunch Hirschberg is counting on. Listen to the full conversation on The Montclair Pod.
If you go: Turtle and the Wolf, 622 Valley Road, Upper Montclair. Lunch Wednesday through Saturday, 11:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m. Dinner Wednesday through Saturday from 5 p.m. and Sunday from 4 p.m. BYOB. Book at turtleandthewolf.com or call 973-783-9800.
Photo Credit: Turtle and the Wolf