We recently launched Fix It, a Montclair Pod series built around one inbox: fixit@montclairpod.com. If you’ve spotted something around town that needs fixing and your own attempts have gone nowhere, you email us and we try to find out why. One of the first messages came from a listener asking the question behind this guide: how do you report a pothole in Montclair and actually get it fixed?
This specific pothole sits at the end of our listener’s driveway on Watchung Avenue. She calls it a sinkhole. It has been there since at least 2020, and over the years she has called the township, Essex County, PSE&G and Verizon about it. Every couple of years someone patches it. Then it sinks again, bigger each time.
It’s still there. So we took her question to the township, where communications director Matt Amaral walked us through how the system works.
Who fixes potholes in Montclair: the town, the county or a property owner?
The owner of the road fixes the pothole, so start there. Every street in Montclair belongs to the township, Essex County or a private owner. There are no state roads in town, and private roads are typically the property owner’s responsibility.
County roads are the ones Essex County owns and maintains, even though they run through Montclair. Many are the roads you drive every day: Bloomfield Avenue, Grove Street and Valley Road are all county roads, and so are Mount Hebron Road and part of Upper Mountain Avenue, to name just a few examples. The township’s Complete Streets director, Jacob Nieman, put together a full list of county and private roads in town on the township website.
Watchung Avenue is a county road, too.
That makes Essex County, not the township, responsible for our listener’s stretch of road. The township says it needs a more precise location to see what else it can find out, and we’re making sure it gets one.
Once you know whose road it is, reporting the pothole is the easy part.
How to report a pothole in Montclair
For a county road, submit an online service request to the Essex County Department of Public Works, or call the county’s pothole hotline at 973-239-3366, ext. 2220.
For a township road, click “Report an Issue” on the township homepage. That link opens REPORT-IT-2-MTC, the township’s online system for logging problems with town services. You can also email info@montclairnjusa.org. If you report a county pothole to the township by mistake, the township says it will forward it to the right people.
Whichever route you take, include the exact address or nearest intersection, a description and photos. Public Works generally handles repairs in the order reports come in but can move more severe problems up the line, so detail helps. After that, you should get an acknowledgment, and you can ask for updates, according to the township.
The system is about to change. Within the next few months, Montclair plans to switch to GovPilot, software designed to send each report straight to the department that handles it.
Why do potholes keep coming back after they’re patched?
Most patches are temporary. A crew fills a small pothole with hot asphalt and packs it down, but the new asphalt doesn’t fully bond with the old road around it. Over time, the patch breaks down.
Utility work adds a second problem. When a road gets dug up so a utility can reach its lines underground, the soil goes back in afterward. If crews didn’t pack it down well, or if the road was repaved too soon, the ground settles and the pavement sinks again.
Utilities are supposed to restore the road when they finish. In practice, the township says, they often bundle repaving jobs together instead of fixing each spot right away.
Amaral told us coordinating with PSE&G on this is “very challenging,” even for the township. The township can help you figure out which utility dug up your street, but it can’t make that utility work any faster.
That leaves one question: what happens when you report a pothole on a county road and nobody comes?
What to do when Essex County doesn’t fix your pothole
The county has no formal escalation process, meaning no official way to push a stalled request up the chain, at least none it has told the township about. The township’s advice is to go the informal route and contact your ward councilor or the county commissioner, either of whom may be able to follow up with the county for you. Montclair’s four ward councilors are Erik D’Amato (1st Ward), Eileen Birmingham (2nd Ward), Rahum Williams (3rd Ward) and Aminah Toler (4th Ward); find yours on the Mayor and Township Council page. The county commissioner for District 5 (Belleville, Bloomfield, Glen Ridge, Montclair and Nutley) is Carlos Pomares.
If you get bounced between the township and the county, remember the township can’t fix county roads. Its staff can, however, point you to the right agency and pass your concern along to their contacts at the county.
Where to report a pothole: contacts and links
- County roads: Essex County Department of Public Works online service request, or the pothole hotline at 973-239-3366, ext. 2220. Main office: 900 Bloomfield Ave., Verona; 973-226-8500.
- Township roads: “Report an Issue” (REPORT-IT-2-MTC) on montclairnjusa.org, info@montclairnjusa.org or 973-744-1400.
- County and private road list: the township’s County and Private Roads page.
- State roads: the township says Montclair has none. If you spot a pothole on a state highway elsewhere, call NJDOT at 1-800-POTHOLE or use its online maintenance report form.
- Utility problems: PSE&G’s online reporting system for issues like streetlight outages, or 1-800-436-7734.
- No response: your ward councilor — Erik D’Amato (1st), Eileen Birmingham (2nd), Rahum Williams (3rd) or Aminah Toler (4th) — or District 5 commissioner Carlos Pomares.
Have something that needs fixing?
Start by finding out who’s responsible, whether that’s the township, the county or a utility. Report it with an exact location and photos, and keep your confirmation or ticket number. If weeks go by and nothing changes, call your ward councilor. And if that goes nowhere, email fixit@montclairpod.com with the details, photos and everyone you’ve already contacted. We’ll see what we can find out.